Some of the animes this season do suck, I agree. However, personally, Puella Magi Madoka Magica is probably my favorite anime ever, and it is currently airing. It is directed by Shinbo and written by Urobuchi. The first episode's is okay, the second sucks but from the third onwards it rocks.
The anime that I'm watching this season are: Puella Magi madoka, Infinite Stratos, Yumekui Merri, Dragon Crisis, and Level E. (I dropped Fractale, it didn't appeal to me) My favs being Puella, Yume, and Level E.